A useful business case says what service the building is considering, which residents need it, what the site can support, who pays over time, and what evidence would justify the next investment. It does not need to promise that charging will raise property value or produce revenue. The U.S. Department of Energy’s multifamily guidance identifies parking, electrical service, billing, legal concerns, and incentives as inputs for owners and managers to assess.
Define the decision before collecting numbers
State the service question in one sentence. For example: “Should this building offer residents shared charging in the existing garage, and if so, should it begin with a pilot or prepare more spaces for later?”
Then record the boundaries that can change the answer:
- building type, parking ownership, assigned and visitor spaces;
- resident groups served, including renters and people without a private stall;
- current charger requests and likely charging times;
- electrical service, meters, routes, and the utility’s requirements, informed by an apartment-building electrical-capacity assessment;
- the proposed access, payment, and support model;
- whether the project is a retrofit, a renovation, or a new build; and
- local approval, funding, accessibility, and permit checks still required.
Ask residents about their parking access, likely vehicle or charging needs, preferred access, and barriers to use. Treat survey answers as input, not as a guaranteed utilization forecast. Include residents who do not have a vehicle yet and those who cannot use a particular stall or app.
When evaluating who can benefit and what barriers a shared service should address, consult this guide to affordable and inclusive charging in social housing.
Compare scenarios, including no on-site build
Compare options using the same resident need, site assumptions, cost period, and service standard.
| Scenario | What to evaluate |
|---|---|
| No on-site charging now | Document a usable alternative, who can access it, its full resident cost over the comparison period, and what conditions would trigger a future review. |
| Small shared service or pilot | Price a limited number of stations plus access, support, billing, and operating work. Define how residents will request and use them. |
| Phased building rollout | Identify the work needed now, the cost of later phases, and the decision points for adding spaces. |
| Building-wide readiness | Compare current assessment and infrastructure work with the building’s likely renovation, service, and parking plans. Do not treat “ready” as equivalent to installed and operating chargers. |
For a public-charging alternative, include the energy price, any session fee or minimum, parking, and idle or overstay charges. As checked on October 29, 2026, the City of Vancouver lists charging and parking separately and an idle fee for DC fast charging; the City of Berkeley lists a base charge, time-varying energy prices, an overstay fee, and possible parking fees. These are local examples, not apartment tariffs. Confirm that residents can use the location and check its current prices before counting it as a fallback.
A project may face high capital costs, limited electrical capacity, or a long installation path. Shared, curbside, mobility-hub, managed-capacity, or other arrangements may be worth asking about, but a case study does not prove the option is available or cheaper at this property. The Canadian MURB barrier analysis notes that parking access, capacity, and governance can be distinct barriers. If the decision is to prepare spaces for later phases, compare it with the apartment-building readiness guide.
Build the financial comparison
For each scenario, show:
- One-time costs: assessment, design, permits, construction, electrical work, equipment, meters, commissioning, and resident communication.
- Recurring costs: electricity, demand-related charges where the tariff applies, network and billing service, support, maintenance, insurance, and replacement. For context, review time-of-use rates and demand charges and confirm the building’s own tariff.
- Funding assumptions: grants, utility contributions, financing, and the party expected to receive or repay each amount.
- Cost allocation: resident, owner, association, utility, or provider responsibilities, including costs that a program excludes.
- No-award case: the budget if a grant is unavailable, delayed, reduced, or not approved.
A City of Palo Alto-commissioned model illustrates how the capital source can change residents’ modeled costs. Over its 2024–2060 model period, levelized annual costs for charging and charger capital per average multifamily resident are about US$1,400 with high public investment, US$1,700 with high private ownership, and US$2,100 with high third-party ownership.
In all three scenarios, the report assigns some upfront service-upgrade costs to the landlord or homeowners’ association and assumes those costs are passed to residents. These are modeled Palo Alto results, not observed bills, quotes, or a ranking that applies to another property. Use the City’s funding study to understand the example; compare another building using its own utility, capital, charging-use, and contract assumptions.
Label quotations, confirmed program awards, historical examples, and planning assumptions separately. A grant announcement or a project elsewhere is not this property’s award, quote, utilization, revenue, or return.
Keep benefit evidence and tax assumptions separate from cash
Record who receives each benefit and what evidence supports it. An amenity, retention, or sale-value claim belongs outside the base cash case unless the property has relevant evidence; record the property and access type, geography, study method, period, denominator, and costs omitted. Survey interest is not forecast use. For each scenario, ask the building insurer or broker about the actual assets and policy, deductible, exclusions, liability, and any quoted premium change; do not infer an EV-specific premium from other properties.
Tax can also change a scenario, but the classification depends on the actual supply, asset, dates, and operator. These current examples show why the assumption must be local:
| Tax input | Current boundary to verify | Business-case treatment |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom electricity | HMRC’s clarification, effective 1 November 2026, treats publicly accessible and workplace charging electricity as non-domestic for VAT and Climate Change Levy. General household supply and some separate private-residential supplies may qualify for relief; the brief does not decide every shared-garage meter or resale arrangement. | Ask a tax adviser to classify the property’s supply and access model before setting a tax-inclusive resident price. |
| New York electricity sales | The State tax department says retail electricity sold at commercial EV charging stations is subject to State and local sales tax. Its proposed 2026–27 exemption was omitted from the enacted budget. | Keep the proposal out of the base case and confirm the current treatment of the property’s billing arrangement. |
| Canadian charging assets | The regulations distinguish qualifying EV charging stations supplying more than 10 kW and certain associated equipment with more than 75% of capacity dedicated to charging. Bill C-15 applies its specified Class 43.1 amendments to property acquired and available for use on or after 17 November 2025. | Asset configuration and dates matter; have a tax professional determine the class and any applicable capital allowance. A deduction is not grant cash. |
Keep the dated authority, property classification, tax-inclusive or exclusive basis, and adviser-confirmed assumption with the scenario. Use the grant budget checklist for conditional payments and reimbursements; keep a tax credit or deduction on a separate line.
Check certification-specific capacity options
For a U.S. new-construction project pursuing DOE Efficient New Homes Multifamily Version 2 certification, check the current EV-Ready Checklist and policy record. The current checklist allows a lower-power alternative when the building has no energy-management system: EVSE can have nameplate output below 6.2 kW, but at least 3.3 kW (16 A at 208/240 V), if the required EVSE spaces increase from 10% to 20% of the lower of dwelling units or resident parking spaces. Under this alternative, no additional EV-Ready or EV-Capable spaces are required.
This certification option does not establish a cost saving. More lower-power spaces change the number and distribution of stations and may change electrical and installation work. Compare both paths with the same resident needs, site capacity, design assumptions, utility requirements, and local code checks. Confirm the current criteria with the project’s rater and designer. This is a U.S. certification pathway for qualifying new construction, not a general code rule or retrofit requirement.
Set decision gates and measures
Before procurement, agree who may approve the project and what information they need. Ask qualified electrical and other professionals to verify design, capacity, permits, and safety requirements. Confirm the ownership and service agreement and the incentive terms before assuming a payment date.
If the property starts with a pilot, set measures that match the service it promised: access, uptime, cost recovery, support response, resident experience, use by intended groups, and capacity for expansion. Decide when the owner will review them and what result would justify keeping, changing, or expanding the service. The shared-charging policy guide can help define access, billing, and service responsibilities. Do not use one utilization target or return threshold for buildings with different parking, resident, and tariff conditions.
Use the cost-component worksheet to make quotes comparable, the ownership comparison to assign responsibilities, and the grant budget checklist to separate confirmed funding from assumptions.